Now, I have a lot of respect for Hollie Smith. Her work on other peoples albums has been outstanding. “Bathe in the River” is an all-time favourite, and almost made me watch No.2 all on its own.
Ever want to feel like some kind of traitor though? Trying saying these words, “Smith’s new album? Dull.”
Unfortunately, it’s true. I’ve tried listening to it a number of times, and all it makes me want to do is to try find Smith playing live somewhere so I can feel reassured I haven’t wasted my money. Probably the problem is bad production.
But it could also be that they songs are uninspired, don’t sound like soul, and seem to rest almost entirely on Smith churning out “whoa-yeah”.
Avoid it if you can. Which will be difficult, since it has ‘cafe backgrounder’ written all over it.
17 July, 2007 at 8:42 pm
Amen brother. Nice voice, but meh. We left her gig last year after 15 minutes – felt like cretins, but frankly it was dull as um, dull things.
18 July, 2007 at 10:39 am
I wouldn’t be so harsh. There is undoubtedly some pap on the record (maybe she would have been wiser to release another EP?), but I think it is a case of her talent waiting to catch up with her voice.
Once she has a few more years behind her, she could be the real deal. Even now, live, on a good night, she can suck the air right out of your lungs…
18 July, 2007 at 11:11 am
well, that’s what i was hoping to hear.
i’m also wishing she would start paying someone else to write songs for her…